wp hatch

← Writing

Membership Site Design That Keeps Members Coming Back

When people talk about membership site design, they usually mean the sales page: the hero, the pricing table, the testimonials. That page matters, but a member sees it once. What they see every week is everything behind the login: the page after checkout, the emails in the first few days, the account page, and the screens they hit when they want to change something.

That second half is where membership sites keep or lose people, and it's the part that gets designed last, if it's designed at all. In our membership site development guide it's system #4, member experience: the layer owners underinvest in and members judge you by. This post goes one level deeper. It covers what we'd design, screen by screen, so that a new member knows what they got, can find it again, and can manage their own account without writing to you.

We build membership sites, and we run one of our own, Board Rats. What follows is the checklist we'd bring to any membership project.

Design for the member, not the visitor

A marketing site is designed for someone deciding. A membership site has to serve someone who already decided and is now trying to get value out of the money they spent. Those are different people with different questions.

The visitor asks should I join? The member asks where is the thing I paid for, and what do I do next? Most membership sites answer the first question beautifully and leave the second to a default theme template and whatever pages the plugin generated.

A useful exercise before any design work: list every screen a member can reach after they sign in, and every email the site can send them. On most projects that list is longer than the marketing sitemap, and nobody has looked at half of it. That list is the brief.

The first screen after checkout

The page a new member lands on after paying is the most important page on the site, and on a lot of sites it's a generic "Thank you for your order" with an order number.

That page should answer three questions in this order:

  1. Did it work? Say plainly that they're a member now, at which level, and that a receipt is on its way to the address they used.
  2. What do I do first? One action, not a menu. Read the start-here post, introduce yourself in the forum, download the first template, book the onboarding call. Pick the single thing that most reliably shows a new member what they paid for, and make it the only big button on the page.
  3. Where will I find things later? Point at the place in the navigation where member content lives, and at the account page. A new member doesn't need the whole map yet, just two landmarks.

Keep the sales copy off it. The decision is made. Repeating the pitch on the confirmation page reads as nervous, and it pushes the one useful action further down the screen.

Design week one as a path

The pillar puts it bluntly: people cancel because they couldn't figure out what they got for their money in week one. So design week one on purpose, as a short path rather than a pile of content.

Order it. If your membership has ten things in it, a new member should meet them one or two at a time, with the most valuable first. A library that opens with everything at once looks generous to the owner and feels like homework to the member.

One email, one job. Each onboarding email should do one thing: a welcome that repeats the first action, a nudge toward the second most valuable feature, an invitation to the community if there is one. An email that tries to tour the whole membership gets skimmed and filed.

Make the path visible on the site, too. A start-here page, a short checklist on the member dashboard, or a "new here?" panel that disappears once they've done the basics. Members don't all read email, and the ones who don't still need the path.

Stop when it's done. Onboarding has an end. Once a member has done the first few things, the welcome panel should go and the onboarding emails should stop. Being welcomed in month three is a sign nobody is watching the automation.

Make the membership visible while they use the site

A member should be able to tell, without visiting the account page, that they're signed in as a member and what that gets them. If the logged-in site looks exactly like the public one, the membership is invisible, and invisible things are easy to cancel.

Small signals do most of the work:

  • A navigation that changes. Signed-in members see their area, their content and their account link. They don't see the "Join" button they already pressed.
  • Labels on member content. Mark what's included in their level, so browsing the site keeps reminding them what they have.
  • A visible marker of membership. On a community site that might be a badge next to a paying member's name. On an ad-supported site it might be the ads switching off once they've joined. Either way, it's something a member notices in normal use, so they don't have to remember what their level includes. The site shows them.

The design question to ask of every member benefit is: where does the member see this? A benefit that only exists on the pricing page is a benefit they'll forget they had.

The locked door

Every membership site has gated content, so every membership site has a locked-door screen, the page someone sees when they reach content they can't open. It's usually designed for exactly one person, the visitor who should be sold a membership. It gets shown to three.

  • A visitor should see what's behind the door and an invitation to join.
  • A member whose session expired should see a sign-in prompt first, not a sales pitch. Asking a paying member to join again is how support emails start.
  • A member on a lower level should see which level includes this, and an upgrade path that keeps their current membership in view.

That means the locked-door screen needs "Sign in" as prominent as "Join", and it needs to know who's looking. Getting this wrong in either direction is an access-control problem as much as a design one, but the design is where members feel it.

The account page is your best support agent

Most membership support email is a question the account page should have answered. Design the account page around the questions members actually ask, in roughly the order they ask them:

  • What do I have? The level they're on, in words, with a short line on what it includes.
  • When will I be charged, and how much? The next renewal date and amount, stated plainly. A member should never be surprised by a renewal they could have seen coming.
  • How do I change it? Update the card, switch levels, change the email address. Each should be a clear action on this page, not a "contact us to change your plan" link.
  • What have I paid? Past receipts, downloadable, so nobody has to ask for an invoice.
  • How do I leave? More on that below. It belongs on this page, findable without a search.

Write the account page in the member's language, not the software's. "Your Pro membership renews on 4 March" is a sentence. "Subscription status: active / Next payment: 2027-03-04" is a database row.

Write the lifecycle emails like screens

Renewal notices, card-expiring reminders, failed-payment messages and cancellation confirmations are part of the design, even though they arrive in an inbox. Most of them ship with the plugin's default wording, which is written for every site at once and sounds like it.

Give each one the same treatment as a page: one clear message, one action, and a link that goes straight to the right place on the account page. A failed-payment email that says what happened, what the member needs to do, and links directly to the update-card screen does more than one that just says "There was a problem with your payment." Keep them in the same voice as the rest of the site, so a member never wonders whether the email is really from you.

Design an honest way out

The cancellation screen is part of the member experience, and it says a lot about the business. Hiding the cancel button, routing it through a contact form or wrapping it in five screens of retention offers might hold onto a few members for a month. It also turns a member who was leaving quietly into one who leaves annoyed and tells people why.

An honest cancellation flow is short:

  1. Findable. On the account page, labelled "Cancel membership", not buried under "Manage subscription settings".
  2. Clear about what happens. Whether access ends now or at the end of the period they've paid for, and what happens to anything they've saved or posted.
  3. One alternative, if you have a real one. If you offer a cheaper level or a pause, show it once. Then let them go.
  4. Confirmed. A confirmation on screen and by email, so they're never unsure whether it worked.

We'd rather a member leave on good terms. Someone who left easily might come back. Someone who had to fight their way out probably won't.

A membership site design checklist

Before launch, and again whenever the membership changes:

  • Every screen a signed-in member can reach is on a list, and someone has looked at each one.
  • The post-checkout page confirms the level, gives one first action and names two landmarks.
  • Week one is an ordered path, on the site and in email, with an end.
  • Signed-in navigation is different from the public navigation.
  • Every member benefit has a place where the member sees it in normal use.
  • The locked-door screen offers "Sign in" as clearly as "Join" and handles members on a lower level.
  • The account page answers: what do I have, when am I charged and how much, how do I change it, what have I paid, how do I leave.
  • Every lifecycle email has one message, one action and a direct link.
  • Cancelling takes a few clicks and ends in a confirmation.

FAQ

What is membership site design?

Membership site design is the design of everything a member uses after they join: the confirmation page, onboarding, the signed-in navigation, gated-content screens, the account page, lifecycle emails and cancellation. The sales page sells the membership. These screens decide whether members feel they're getting what they paid for.

What should a membership account page include?

The member's current level and what it includes, the next renewal date and amount, actions to update a card, change level or change email, past receipts, and a findable way to cancel. If members regularly email you to ask something, that answer belongs on the account page.

How do you onboard new members on a membership site?

Give them one clear first action on the page after checkout, then a short, ordered path through the first week: a few emails that each do one job, matched by a start-here page or dashboard checklist on the site. Lead with the thing that most reliably shows a member what they paid for, and stop the onboarding once they've done it.

Should it be easy to cancel a membership?

Yes. Put cancellation on the account page, say clearly when access ends, offer one genuine alternative if you have one, and confirm it. Making it hard keeps a few members briefly and costs you goodwill with everyone who notices.

Designing a membership site?

If you're planning a membership site, or you have one whose member screens nobody has looked at in a while, talk to us. We'll start with the screens your members actually use. You can also see our work first.